Blog

Settle How Your Office Handles a STOP Before November 25

The FCC's new TCPA opt-out rules take effect Nov. 25. How insurance agencies should handle STOP replies, sort their texts, and keep every opt-out in sync.

Greg Spano

The opt-out rules I wrote about in October finally have a date, and it's the day before Thanksgiving.

In October I said the FCC's new opt-out order would take effect 30 days after it hit the Federal Register, and to confirm the date with counsel before you changed anything. It was published October 26, so the date is November 25. That leaves about a week, and it's Thanksgiving week, to decide how your office handles a STOP. These are the four things I'd settle first:

  • Decide whether to name your opt-out methods. The FCC now lets you designate the exact ways a customer opts out, as long as you disclose them clearly in every call and text that needs consent. If you don't designate any, you're still on the hook for any reasonable way a customer tells you to stop.

  • Sort your texts into informational and marketing. An opt-out from a payment reminder can now stay with payment reminders, but an opt-out from marketing still ends every marketing touch from your agency. Where a renewal text that offers a re-quote lands is a question for your counsel.

  • Make all seven words work. Your texts can show one keyword, like STOP, but quit, end, revoke, opt out, cancel and unsubscribe all still count.

  • Time how long a STOP takes to reach the dial list. The limit is still 10 business days, and the FCC is asking whether to cut it to seven. A STOP that sits in a shared inbox over Thanksgiving weekend uses up more of that window than most offices expect.

What's new since October

The order itself, FCC 26-67, is the one the FCC adopted on September 30. It was published in the Federal Register on October 26 and takes effect November 25, replacing the January 31, 2027 date that had been set for the broader "revoke all" rule. CommLaw Group's advisory makes the point I'd underline for any owner: both new options are optional. If you do nothing, your current obligations stay exactly where they are.

As a quick recap, the final rule gives you two choices. You can treat an opt-out from an informational call or text as covering only that category, and you can designate exclusive opt-out methods: a keypress or voice option on a call, a reply keyword on a text, or a website or phone number you set up. Marketing doesn't get the narrower treatment, a text that shows one keyword still has to honor all seven, and the 10-business-day limit stays in place.

The part that's new is the further notice that came with the order. Comments are due November 25 and replies December 28, per Womble Bond Dickinson, and anyone can file in CG Docket 02-278, including a state agents association. The FCC is asking about four things:

  • A seven-business-day deadline. The idea comes from a June 30 joint letter by the American Bankers Association, the National Consumer Law Center and ACA International.

  • Replies as opt-outs. Whether every text sender should have to accept a reply as an opt-out, possibly only on marketing texts.

  • A revoke-all option. Whether the category option should only be available to callers who also offer one way to stop everything at once.

  • Affiliates and divisions. How an opt-out should carry across separate companies, lines of business or offices. Today's do-not-call rule applies a request to the calling entity, and to affiliates only where the consumer would reasonably expect it.

None of that is adopted. Plan around today's rule and keep an eye on these through the winter.

Cartoon — Thanksgiving Opt-Out (Greg, Quoted & Loaded, Nov 17)

Where the STOP gets lost

A lot of times when I ask an agency where their STOP replies go, the answer takes a minute. The owner knows the policy. What nobody's traced is the path a STOP takes from the customer to every list that might contact them next, and in my experience it gets lost in the same few places.

The shared inbox. Replies land wherever whoever's on watch happens to see them. A STOP that comes in Friday afternoon, with the CSR who watches that inbox out Monday, is already burning business days before anyone reads it.

The producer's own phone. A producer texts a quote from their cell to save time, the customer replies STOP, and that reply lives on one phone and nowhere else.

The outside team. A lot of agencies hired third-party callers, many of them outside the US, to keep outbound going at a cost that made sense. Their do-not-call list and yours often don't talk to each other.

The aged-lead list. The best shops run a cadence 45 to 60 days deep and use the full 90-day window to bring someone back to market. That only works if the list stays current. A re-quote list pulled into a spreadsheet in August doesn't know about the STOPs that came in since.

The carrier's tool. On the captive side, a lot of carriers are consolidating tech from corporate down and controlling which texting platforms agents can use. An opt-out recorded in the carrier's tool doesn't automatically reach the dialer you bought yourself.

None of this comes from anyone being careless on purpose. People make mistakes, and the process has to catch them before a customer has to say stop twice.

Sorting your messages

The category option only helps if you know which bucket each message sits in. This is how I'd sort the texts most agencies send, with your counsel making the final call:

  • Payment reminders and billing notices: informational.

  • ID cards, policy documents and claim status updates: informational.

  • Renewal notices that only tell the client what's coming: likely informational.

  • A renewal text that offers to re-quote or re-shop: likely marketing, because it invites new business.

  • Quote follow-up on a lead, cross-sell, and rounding out the household: marketing.

  • A message that does both: treat it as marketing until counsel tells you otherwise.

Most agency lead outreach sits in the marketing bucket, so the category option mostly helps on the service side. The quoted-not-sold cadence still ends when that person says stop.

Infographic — Which Bucket Is Your Text In (Greg, Quoted & Loaded, Nov 17)

What designating actually takes

If you decide to name your opt-out methods, write the whole process down once. That means which methods you're designating, the exact disclosure line, where it appears on every call and text that needs consent, where a STOP gets recorded, and who checks that record every day. That's a process you can train a new CSR on in an afternoon.

Then decide what a CSR does when a customer says "quit texting me" on the phone or at the counter, which isn't one of your designated methods. My advice is to honor it anyway and log it the same day. The rule may not require it once you've designated, but the customer who said stop and kept hearing from you is the one who calls a lawyer.

If you run more than one location or share an outbound setup across agents, how an opt-out at one office applies to another is a call for your counsel. Captive agents should also check what their carrier has approved before changing disclosure language or adding a tool. I'm not a lawyer, and this isn't legal advice, so run your process past your own counsel before November 25.

What it looks like when a STOP goes nowhere

TCPAWorld covered a ruling in late October that shows how this plays out. In Rubin v. Staples, a New Jersey federal court let a class action move forward on October 26. The plaintiff alleges he kept getting marketing texts after repeatedly replying "Stop," and his claims rest on Staples' internal do-not-call obligations, the list a STOP is supposed to land on. Staples argued he had consented to the texts. The court said consent is a defense to fight on the merits, so the case goes to discovery. That includes whether his "Stop" replies ever reached Staples' systems.

It lines up with the Florida ruling from August, where a federal court held that a STOP to a text may revoke consent for calls too. Taken together, they point a court at one question: whether the opt-out reached every channel that contacted this person afterward. A lot of times the STOP did come in. It just never made it from the text thread to the list the next producer dials from.

You may have seen the other headline going around. The Seventh Circuit held in July that a text isn't a "telephone call" for a private do-not-call lawsuit, and a Texas magistrate judge reached the same answer in October. Courts elsewhere, including the one hearing the Staples case, still let those claims go forward. Either way, those rulings are about one kind of lawsuit. They don't change the FCC's opt-out rule, consent for automated marketing texts, state laws like Texas's, or the carriers that filter your texts. I'd keep honoring every STOP the same way.

One next step

Pick one customer from last month who asked to stop hearing from you, and trace where that request went: the notes, the texting tool, the dialer, the CRM. Count how many places it had to be typed by hand. A lot of agencies find the gap between the text thread and the dial list, because they live in two different systems. At Mav, a STOP ends that lead's cadence on text and voice together, so nobody has to remember to key it in a second time.

Before you go

Of the four things up top, naming your methods, sorting your messages, the seven words, or the time a STOP takes to reach the dial list, which one is hardest to answer in your shop right now? Tell me, and what I hear back tells me what to get into next. All said, the agencies that come through November 25 cleanly will be the ones that can show where every STOP went.

FAQs

Do I have to designate an opt-out method by November 25?

No. Both new options are optional. If you don't designate, any reasonable way a customer tells you to stop still counts, same as today.

If a client opts out of payment reminders, can I still text them a renewal re-quote?

The new rule lets an informational opt-out stay with that category, so marketing consent can survive it. A re-quote is likely marketing, though, so make sure you have consent for it on its own and have counsel sign off on how you're sorting messages before you rely on that.

Is the seven-business-day deadline in effect?

No. It's one of the questions in the further notice. Today's limit is 10 business days.

Does a STOP on a text stop my calls too?

Plan as if it does. A marketing opt-out ends all marketing calls and texts from you under the rule, and the Florida court in August held a STOP to a text may revoke consent for calls.

Do the do-not-call rules even apply to texts anymore?

It depends on the court right now. The Seventh Circuit says no for private lawsuits, other courts say yes, and state laws and the FCC's opt-out rule still apply either way. Plan as if they cover texts.

Who should I follow to get the most up-to-date information on TCPA rules?

Eric J. Troutman, the Czar of the TCPA. His blog, TCPAWorld, usually has a new ruling written up within a day or two of it coming out, and it's where I check first when something changes.

Greg Spano

Ready to grow your book?

Mav will make your phone ring.